Supplies Needed:
Crockpot
Candy Thermometer (need to measure 115*)
Cheesecloth or thin tea towel
Colander
Large Bath Towel
Cooler (large enough to hold your crock pot insert)
Milk (your choice 2%, whole, organic, etc.)
Yogurt Starter (Plain, Greek is my choice)
1. Fill your crock pot with your choice of milk and cover. Heat to 115* EXACTLY
(This took less than 1 hour on high in my crock pot). If you accidentally get too high just cool it off until you get it back to the needed temp.
2. When your milk reaches 115* EXACTLY remove a ladle full of your milk and mix with 1/4C of your Plain Yogurt Starter in a separate bowl. Once mixed well add them both back to your crock pot. Replace Lid.
3. Place a large bath towel on your table fully opened.
4. Remove your crock pot insert and place in the middle of the bath towel. Wrap the crock pot insert with bath towel.
5. Place the wrapped crock pot insert in your cooler. Close cooler lid. Allow to “cook” for 7-12 hours. The longer you cook it, the tarter flavored yogurt you get.
6. When you have cooked your yogurt to your desired flavor, you are ready to strain the whey from it. Sit a colander lined with cheese cloth or a cotton tea towel in a stock pot that is deeper than the colander itself. (The colander edges should sit over the stock pot creating a space for the whey to fall below. Make sure the two of these units together can still fit on a refrigerator shelf)
7. Pour your cooked yogurt from your crock pot into the lined colander. Fold any remaining fabric up where it is not hanging off the sides and stick in the fridge. The whey will soak into the fabric and will leak onto your refrigerator shelves if it hangs down. The whey straining process takes all day or night depending on when you make your yogurt!
8. After about 10 hours or so of straining you will be left with thick, creamy yogurt. Discard the whey and scoop the yogurt into any container of your choice. (We use leftover plastic yogurt containers). Refrigerate for up to 7 days!
**The cooked yogurt consistency before you strain the whey is very thin. Somewhere between milk and yogurt.
**The strained whey should fill up several inches of your stock pot and is yellow tinted looking water.
You can use the plain yogurt as a sour cream replacement or flavor with your choice sweetner.
I flavor my yogurt with maple syrup and vanilla. You can add frozen or fresh fruit. Use the yogurt for smoothies, etc.